A new U.S. Justice Department Office of Legal Counsel opinion says the word “State” in Section 404 of the 1996 federal welfare law includes all component agencies of a participating state or territory. The opinion expressly includes the U.S. Virgin Islands within the law's definition.
For governments receiving Temporary Assistance for Needy Families funding, the statute requires reporting identifying information on people the government knows are unlawfully present in the United States. The new opinion withdraws a 1998 interpretation that had largely confined that responsibility to the agency administering the covered benefit program.
The opinion says the obligation applies prospectively and does not authorize retroactive penalties for jurisdictions that followed the former interpretation. It also argues that the statutory knowledge threshold can be met in some circumstances without a final removal order, while acknowledging that existing federal regulations use a narrower standard.
This is an Office of Legal Counsel interpretation that guides the federal executive branch, not a ruling from a federal court. No territory-specific implementation procedure from the Virgin Islands government was found with the opinion, leaving open how agencies will verify status, prevent mistaken reports and handle protected information.
The V.I. government should publish legal guidance before implementation defining which agencies must report, what qualifies as verified knowledge, who reviews a referral, how people can correct errors and how confidential information will be protected.
Source published September 1, 2026. Read the original reporting or release for the complete record.
Open original source